The evidence comes first.

Read the basis before the verdict.

What KnifeCritic publishes

KnifeCritic is a publication about everyday carry and outdoor cutting tools. This first edition contains research-led buying guidance and manufacturer specification profiles. We have not completed hands-on tests of the products in this catalogue.

Three different kinds of evidence

Manufacturer specifications describe what a maker publishes for an identified variant. Editorial guidance sets out questions and tradeoffs. Hands-on testing requires an identified sample, method, observations and limitations. We do not label the first two as the third.

How to use a specification profile

Maker fields identify a variant; they do not establish comfort, cutting life or long-term reliability. If possible, handle the exact version and read its operating instructions before choosing.

No invented scores or winners

There are no performance scores, star ratings or best-overall awards in this edition. A steel rating cannot stand in for a finished-knife test. Missing information stays missing; source conventions and conflicts remain visible.

Sources and changes

Each profile links to its original source and records the date checked. Guides identify their external research when they make a sourced claim. A checked date records our observation, not a promise that a manufacturer has changed nothing since.

Commercial links

Some knife profiles have a “Where to buy” section with retailer links through the AvantLink affiliate network. If you buy through one of these links, we may earn a commission. The section says so before the first link, and each link shows the date we checked it. We show a price only when it comes from a retailer feed, with the date we read it. Commissions do not decide what we write, and this edition has no sponsored rankings or paid placements. Manufacturer source links stay ordinary links.

Images and authorship

Outdoor photographs are generic editorial images. Product photographs come from the identified manufacturers and show reference products, not samples we tested. Articles use an organizational editorial byline; no individual tester or credential is invented. Read the sources and image credits.